A Multicultural Approach to Learning
by 'Inoke Fotu Hutakau
Community Information officer: Blacktown District
Office
Department of Education and Training
Background information
Students of Pacific Island background were either born in the pacific
island or their parents were originally from the islands. Migrants
from the Pacific regions are mainly from Fiji, Tonga, Samoa and
the Cook Islands. There are also a few from Nine, Tokelau, Tahiti
and Tuvalu. It is also important to acknowledge that within this
group there are generally two main categories: students who migrate
directly from the island and those who are born overseas. Since
language learning is greatly influence by the social and in general
physical environment of the learner, the distinction mentioned in
the context of their background should be be kept in mind.
Pacific Island student is not only a fast growing group in the
NESB student population, but their share of the problems in relation
to learning justify granting them special attention. While they
are capable for succeeding in comparison to any group of students,
the available statistics have shown that these students are struggling
in their academic career. This short article is an attempt to give
a much more reliable profile and highlight the cultural factors
that need to be considered by the teaching staff and parents alike
in any attempt to assist students of pacific island background.
However, some of the issues raised, approach and views taken in
this analysis can be applied to student group of other cultural
background.
Language
Breaking the language barrier is still the mainstay of cross-cultural
educational approach. In regards to language, it is crucial to note
that Pacific island cultures are oral cultures; their history and
traditions are handed down orally from generation to generation.
Although the development of written form of these languages are
not more than 2OO years old, the oral tendency is still very strong.
In learning a second language these students would naturally response
better to oral exercises rather than the written ones. Thus the
discrepancies between their oral and written skills in literacy
needs closer attention. Pacific island students who are New Zealand
or Australian born are likely to show this type of discrepancies
more than those who migrated
directly from the islands. overseas born pactfic island students
may have oral skills and a natural feel for English (language) induced
by their dominant environment. Their skills in their native language
depends on a number of factors: exposure to it in formal education,
its usage in the home, religions, educational background of parents
and whether they are bilingual. However, student will maintain their
oral skill much longer but in time tend to lose the ability to read
and write.
As mentioned before, pacific island students that have started
education or have spend at least three years in Australia, their
knowledge of English is much more balanced because of its dominant
place in school and the wider community. Their feel for the language
is becomeing more natural. Further on in their academic career,
if their oral skills is not well support by rigorous literacy program,
some discrepancies between their knowledge of english and native
language will be easily identified.
The first language debate in the communities: Which language is
the student's first language? have caused so much confusion when
the main issue which is 'learning'is confused with the community's
cultural sentiment. The question is not that hard to answer if the
determinant is their current physical and social environment, not
what we believed it to be. The issue is not the language we aspire
to but language in the context of our social environment. The community
debate on the subject is marred by an emotional bend of conservatism
in many communities which lead to further confusion. However, the
fact remains, that if they are treated as bilingual, they have to
have a good knowledge of or master one language in order to learn
another well. If the confusion regarding the direction of their
bilingualism ( English --> Ton-Sam etc. or Ton- Sam-etc --->Eng)
is not resolved, it will drastically affect their language development.
There is also a different time frame associated with each bilingual-direction.
If English is treated as their first language, they are far more
advantaged by the resources available as well as their surroundings
for its study. The student can choose to study another language
later on in their educational career, and that can be the place
of origin language . If a native language is treated as the first
language and the study of English evolves in the student's knowledge
of that language then there are two issues to consider: Firstly,
the first language can only be effectively utilised if the teacher
is bilingual in that language, if not, the students only rely on
their own knowledge to make the corresponding comparison between
the two languages. If as in countless occasions, the student understanding
of the first language is limited to its oral form, then to proceed
to the written form in the second language will be much more difficult
for both teacher and student to assess the value of the native language
to acquisition the second one.
It is a different issue, if the object is bilingualism, for the
interrelation between the two or more languages is assumed to be
in par. What should be pointed out at this stage is that raising
children bilingually is not an easy task. LenoreArnberg in her book
(Arnberg 1987) gives a simple and straightforward account of the
process and the problem to prepare parents if they wish to persue
a bilingual program for their children.
However, there seems to be a strong correlation between language
profeciency and academic performances. of the 2.676 NESB students
in the secondary support class, 7O.O% were enrolled at the intensive
English centres. (Bulletin Report, ISSN lO3O-O4O5)
Social environment
Socially, Pacific Island cultures operate on a broader social kinship
model based on the extended family system. In that context, the
emotional network that children grow up in is much broader than
what is normally the case in westernised countries. Children of
these communities grew up trusting a broader spectrum of family
and community members than what is considered safe in most industrilized
countries like Australia. In that sense, pacific island students
are far more emotionally sensitive and trusting than what their
macho image would allow one to believe. They do things according
to how they feel about them and the way that their family and wider
community valued certain activity.
The emotional orientation of a Pacific Islander is an outward one,
toward his family, village and lastly his country. This socialised
peer pressure becomes the pacific islanders traditional support
system. To do things simply for ones own self interest and satisfaction
is the lowest act and this is quite common in other cultures. But
in the diverse Australian society the values of self- reliance and
independence are encouraged as the norm. The students, in interacting
with the mainstream trend, have gained enough experience of these
values and have seeked independence using different means to weaken
their traditional support value-system viz. family and community,
leaving their teenage peer environment dominant. This phase of student
social transition involved huge confusion and that is when they
are vulnerable to the negative elements of their new environment.
Without the pressure of their traditional support system they are
more vulnerable to peer pressure than their counterpart. To think
objectively without any subjective bend is a new skill to be learned
but until then, their feelings greatly influenced their judgement.
If the abundance of distracting elements and the complexity of their
new environment is taken into account, it is much harder for these
students to fixed a goal and follow a set procedures to achieve
it. It is not that they do not want to, it is a skill that needs
re-enforcement because of their cultural background.
The economic factor
In case of Pacific Islanders, it would be interesting to note some
of these factors and lookout for their consequences. However, we
are not dealing with an unskilled or low literacy group of people
but with a highly skilled and motivated group. The issue is "appropriateness";
whether their experience and skill is appropriate and can be utilized
in their new environment. If certain experince and background are
relevant and applicable; What are they? If they need to aquire new
ones; What are they? and How they are to be achieved?
However, the reality of their situation in a much more complicated
society, there are few facts to be acknowledged: most pactfic island
families can be classified at the lower margin of the low income
category. Demographic information shows a low level of skilled migrants
emigrating from the pacific islands.
It is typical in these families for both parents to work and still
stays at the marginal range of the low income category.
Since most island economies rely heavily on remittances from their
oversee communities it indicates that a major portion of the family
income is diverted away from the family needs. although most families
identified educational opportunities as the main motive for migrating,
the allocation of resources does not indicate this ambitions.
The ritualistic character or cultural practices is most obvious
in religious activities. Certain ways of conducting religious activities
which was suitable in the island setting and lifestyle are costly
in a more complicated social setting in terms of resources such
as time and money. In certain cases, scarce resources are being
diverted away from the essential needs of families toward unrealistic
projects and expectations. But the fact of the matter is that, the
transition is from less to a more physically complicated environment
and from a more homogenous to a culturally diverse society. These
guarantee that the process of migratory-transition is from the beginning
an uphill struggle for most migrant communities and individual families.
It should also be acknowledged that Australia in the context of
its resettlement program has done and achieved more than most countries
through different forms of welfare and employment programs. It has
also advanced further in the equity front with legislative changes
through its multicultural and reconciliation policies in all areas
of social development. The object then is to enhance the progress
along the path that has been established for the purpose of achieving
a diverse and socially cohesive society.
Cultures
The PacificIslands are inhabited in most part by the Polynesian
race to the north and southwest and the melanesian to the southeast.
Physically their physique match the demand of their seafaring life
and environment. The ocean dominated region, oft referred to as
Oceania is as culturally diverse as those in any continent. In its
socio-politico makeup, from one extreme is the service oriented
functional socialist of Samoa to the Absolute Divine Monarchy of
Tonga on the other. Socially, it ranges from less to highly stratified.
Language wise, it ranges from common to highly stratified such as
the three tiered language of Tonga correspond to its social strata
and heirachy of power. While their distinctness can be highlighted,
their general characteristics of being easygoing and fun-loving
people is the image that has captivate foreigners since the age
of discovery. But, like any other society, both the Polynesian and
the Melanesian have their share of conflicts, savagery and peaceful
existence. Their heavily build phisique and physical attitude to
work and generally living can be menacing to others. However, the
core cultural factors discussed in this section: mentality, maturity
and spontaneity from a social perspective, may assist the school
community to understand this group of student better.
The most distinctive feature of Pacific island culture is the concept
that is build on, the concept of "indirectness". Their way of life
is like a form of 'social poetry' with imagery and metaphor everywhere.
Any activity is for the actor to tune onto it mentally and once
that is done, the mental state harness the physical power to act
and the activity becomes spontaneous. They conduct their affairs
in a round about way, where one can express huge as small and a
feat as an ordinary act; this is still evident in cultural ceremonies
where one party is being presented to another. But as small society
which function on inter-personal and communal level, privacy is
valued highly simply because it is near impossible to be realised.
Thus the private domain of life is guarded by the social concept
of 'tapu' or sanctity, whether it is physical environment, social
in the community sense, or individual in the emotional and physical
sense of the term.
A concept of time
I strongly believe that the functional mode that the concept of
time played in the development of sciences in different societies
and different mode of economic operation have caused cultures to
embody time in different ways. It thus seems that the more complex
the economy is the more refined, confine, precise and even narrow
their conception of time. In the Australian situation there seems
to be two distinct mode and ways of time in operation, one is prevalent
in the indegeneous and non-english-speaking background cultures
and another by the main-stream western oriented culture.
In fact one is the socialised of time which is so fluid and loosely
linked and often manifested in sequence with no clear boundary:
night, day, sunrise, sunset, dawn, dusk, early morning, afternoon,
late afternoon and so on. In this socialised conception, time is
seen as important only in term of an activity to be done. Time is
then imposed on the quality or the outcome of the activity. In other
words time is only sign)ficant in the sense that it is superimpose
upon what needs to be done; time is not real, the activity is. In
this sense, a waste of time really means a waste of effort not because
of the time spend but the expected outcome and quality was not achieved.
Time in itself does not mean anything; time is generalised in terms
of the activity associated with it.
On the other hand is the mechanical conception and calibration
of time embodied by the clock: seconds, minute, hour, micro dimension
such as nanosecond and macro dimension such as a lightyear. Time
in this sense is seen in a structural form, where in contrast to
the former conception, time is seen as the structure we superimpose
our social activities. Time in itself is as real as the activity.
It seems that the more commercialised societies operate on the
mechanical concept of time as a necessity for transactions, transport
and in general trade. It has become an instrument of "activity made
easy" tool. They function with a sanctioned degree of predictability.
The less commercialised societies still operate on socialised form
of time, therefore very flexible. To move from one mode of time-conception
to the other is one of the hardest part of adaptation needed when
one becomes a migrant in either form of society. Specifically, if
one migrates from a less to a more commercialised society and vice
versa. The pactfic island migrants falls in this category, transit
from a fluid to a rigid time concept. The incompatibility of socialised
and the mechanical mode of time is quite obvious in pactfic island
students. Thus the social infrastructure although highly functional
is so fluid in the way it deals with time.
Taking the different cultural orientation to the concept of time
into account and specifically for pactfic island students, there
are two things that should be part of their training: organisation
and time-management skills. organisation, because of the fluidity
and unpredictability of activities at home and generally social
environment; time-management drills should be part of their training
at the earliest to ensure a more predictable and routine mode of
operation. Especially with the latter, the drill method should be
applied until the adaptation to the mechanical concept of time becomes
habitual. The importance of certain time-factor such as 'deadline'
and 'due date' and the implication of missing out on reward and
merits has to be emphasized by drill method until it become part
of their psyche.
Maturity, is not a matter of age but a state of mind. It is acquiring
and understanding of values. One distinctive factor in PacificI
Island students is that most of them were brought up in a cultural
system which view independence and maturity as a much later development
in life than what is normally the case in western type cultures.
This kind of mature dependency can easily be carried over to the
school environment. In most cases they hesitate do something on
their own based on their best judgement without the assurance or
even at time implied assurance of someone, that may be a teacher
or a friend. At times they appear to be indifferent when they are
asked about something simply for fear of possible deluge. Some activity
may be a new experience and they do feel secure simply because they
have not done it before; in other word they go by their feeling.
They enter a new territory and not feeling good about it. If these
are taken to be the case then it is much more advantageous for the
educational career of these students to say that they need more
direct coaching and attention to break them into a learning environment
regardless of the year of entry, then what is normally the case
in the school system.
Objectivity versus subjectivity
Crucial for the success of these students is the teacher-student
relationship. As mentioned before, these students are more trusting
than what they seem to be, and much of their performance in subject
hinges on their attitude toward the teacher and vice versa.
In the initial encounter with their school environment Pacific
island student do not look for teacher or instructor, they seek
someone whom they can trust. Their view of teacher is more in line
with the idea of a mentor. With this kind of sensitivity and emotional
attitude toward learning, the worst thing that can happen to a pactfic
islander students is to be taught by a teacher who has no emotional
attachment to what he or she does. To teach with a kind of abstract
objectivity will victimised these students. A trusting relation
between teacher and student should be established at the earliest
possible stage of the learning process. once this trust is established,
the flow of information between the school, student and parents
is much more enhanced.
Since these cultures is much more effective when activities are
backup by an emotional urge, the time frame of the effectiveness
of this mode of operation is short term. This phenomenon among pactfic
islanders can be observed best in artistic performance whether it
is dancing, poetry or singing.
There is a general view in the school community that pacific islanders
love to sing and dance; the point is, they love to because they
feel good about doing it. Singing aroused the individual emotion
to participate; at the same time lift the emotional atmosphere of
warmth and the artistic dimension and quality of the actively. This
aspect of the culture has been effectively exploited by certain
institution or I rather say that the exploitation of this aspect
of the culture has been institutionalised in religion as well as
other institutions for the purpose of fund raising effectively.
The issue is how to utilise this spontaneity for educational purposes.
As suggested above, the key lies in their feelings toward such activity;
they have to feel good about it in order to do it. It is not the
case that they do it first and feel good about it later. This distinction
influence their career choice. Teacher may have noticed by now that
at year 10 onward, when pactfic island students are confronted with
question about the career they want to pursue, it is often answered
with a smile and a degree of uncertainty. It is not the case that
they are lazy and indecisive. To these students, choosing a career
path is related or at best closely associated to the subject they
feel comfortable with, the way that it is being taught or one taught
by a teacher they can relate to at school.
The learning process: learning style
The way that humans learn or the process of gaining knowledge is
still very much a topic of philosophical debate. But the issue is
not how the Tongans, Samoan and Fijian or any particular group learn
or gain knowledge, but still 'how do humans learn'. Fortunately
by convention there is a working knowledge of human process of learning;
human learns by way of experience and by conceptualising over his
experience. Western civilisation, since the Greeks have adopted
conceptual thinking in western philosophy and the development of
science have stretched experiential learning to the highest level
that mankind have ever experienced before. Pacificislanders as human
learn the same way but the process in the development of their civilisation
is more a product of experiential learning and deductive logic more
than anything else. The way they conceptualise over their experience
seems to be limited by their practicality. The fact of the matter
is, Cultural groups whether from pactfic islands or elsewhere have
no peculiar way of learning or learning style that cannot be accounted
for by the conventional theory of learning.
In case of groups with similar background to pactfic islander,
a methodology or lesson plan which emphasised the experiential approach
to learning, as the basis of their learning orientation is likely
to be more effective. Traditionally for these students they will
find mathematics and science difficult, but who does not. It does
not mean they are impossible at these subject, it is solely depend
on the way they are being taught. An approach which is based on
an intensive explanation of theories and use the experiment to justify
certain conclusion may not be effective with these students. An
approach which use experiments and physical occurrences in their
environment to establish why we arrive at certain theory will be
much more effective.
Necessary skills
one of the most crucial distinction between societies is the differences
in degree of commmercialisation.It seems that the more commercialised
a society is, the more familiar are its members with the demand
for efficiency in resource management including time. Migrants from
lesser or not yet commercialised societies have a more loose attitude
toward time. Management of resource may not be a problem because
the experience of managing resources in the context of abundance-scarcity
cycle is part of any society.
Pacific Islanders are known for their easy going attitude toward
time. As a major portion of their society still operate at the subsistence
level and the pressure of a fully mechanised money economy is a
new experience and skills to learn.
Motivation and ambitions
The prevalent view in the school system is that pactfic island
students are generally not motivated and ambitious enough in their
pursuit of their academic career. But it is a fact that any degree
of 'confusion' as well as other mode of mental state can blunt others
in the similar category of similar state.
Motivation is borne out of a closely related or linked state or
process mental state. It not a simple matter of instruction and
acquiring as it is assumed in countless program and thinking on
the issue. It invoolve clarity of objective and direction. It involved
perseverance and persistence. It involved and assumed certain level
of ability and skills. If a child cannot aquire certain level of
competency in a cross-section of these factors in their learning
process then to expect from them a state of mind which is labelled
as being motivated and ambitious is unrealistic and grossly unfair.
Human have operated on a certain degree of a network of the above
state of mind in any walks of life irrespective of culture since
antiquity. We cannot assume that it is lacking in certain group
of people and abundant in others; it is a case of whether a network
of different state of mind form an infrastructure to network for
the purpose of achieving certain level of operation in human activity
and orientation. That is motivation. To be ambitious is simply a
matter of human instinctive inclination and the path to it is motivation.
Self-esteem
Self-esteem is a catch-phrase in the school community at present.
It is generally assumed that if a student is not of the dominant
culture then it is more than likely to suffer from low self-esteem
without any qualification. The confusion on this issue can be attributed
to the fact that there are two distinct aspects to self-esteem;
Feeling good about what one does and Feeling good about oneself
are two separate issue even though they may be related in certain
cases.
Feeling good about
oneself can
often be determined by these factors:
- culture and civilisation
of country of origin
- family background
- attitude and personality
- Socio-economic status
in relation to education and profession
- international status
of country of origin
But as mentioned earlier, since the idea of racial superiority
has subsided from the mind of social scientist, all cultures can
stand their ground in debate about superiority. Together with the
currency of nationalism as outcomes of the demise of colonialism
there are fewer reason for students to have low self-esteem in this
sense. Even with the socio-economic factor, the community is so
diverse that it is hard to form a general opinion or to categorise
a group as such simply because they fit one or all of these factors.
On the other hand, there is a lot of misconception and accusation
of laziness, concentration problems, rudeness, attention getter
(now a disorder) or whatever way of describing antilearning behaviour.
Pacific Island students seem not to be interested in learning and
their academic progress. This is where the second case of self-esteem
features, feeling good about what one does, has some bearing
on their academic performances. As explained earlier, Pacific island
cultures operate on the subjective mode. Their performance is greatly
influenced by the way they feel about the activity. In most cases,
the efficiency of their performance depends on how they feel at
any particular time. They have to feel good about the activity in
order to do it effectively. It is not in their custom to do it and
then feel good about it afterward. once it is done, it is up to
others to appreciate it; it is not culturally appropriate for the
performer of the feat to be directly involved in the appreciation.
Thus self esteem in the educational sense depends on a number of
factors:
- teacher's attitude
toward their pacific islanders
- the way teachers feel
about teaching in general
- whether there is trust
in the student teacher relation
- how genuine is the
teacher's concern about the students' progress
But since their experience is dominantly in the emotional mode
of operation, they can pick up in no time pretentious behaviours
and treat such person with care or avoid totally any contact with
the person.
In relation to their schooling, feeling good about a task depends
upon different factors: the teacher's attitude toward the student
and other aspects of the student- teacher relation. In general,
pacific island students are emotionally sensitive and attached to
these factors.
The teaching staff may not realise the vulnerability of these students
in this respect. Just having them in the classroom with teachers
who do not emotionally involved in what they do is the worst case
scenario for these group of students. one thing about cultures which
activities is still dominates by the subjective mode of operation.
They feel their way through the routine of their daily life. That
does not mean that they are incapable of treating things objectively;
it is only to draw our attention to the fact that if we are looking
for a cultural reason of why certain group generally act in a particular
way, we may trace it to certain customary mode of activity which
dominate the activities in their culture.
Discipline: a cultural perspective
To drill the human psyche to adhere to a certain set of social
behaviour which mold a certain culture have been manifested in a
variety of ways. one favourable way popular throughout human history
until recently is the physical drill of the needed behavious which
go hand in hand with physical punishment. The most recent resurgent
of human rights and the right of children at all level has outlawed
the use of corporal punishment as means of discipline. Especially
with the less commercially developed countries, we are still at
the cross-road of the parenting generation that grew up in the drill-punishment
format caring for a generation born into a totally new conception
of discipline. Discipline in the modern era is psychologically drilled
minus the corporal punishment.
Institutional perspective school perspective
Discipline is an issue often raised in schools regarding Pacific
island students. It seems to be the case that pactfic island student
who have discipline plroblem at school generally fall in one of
these categories:
(i) his or her behaviour at school is not evident at home
(ii) parents have very low profeciency in english
(iii) parents both work and the student grew up most of the time
unsupervised or supervise by others (relatives)
(iv) child literacy level is very low with respect to age and class.
(v) child do not live with parents
There are other factors that may contribute to the child discipline
problem, but the few mentioned so far may help to highlight others.
Whatever the discipline problem may be, teachers would find these
few pointers helpful in dealing with pacific island students.
- make sure that the parents understand the problem you have experienced
with their child.
- that the student understand that his/her behaviour is not acceptable
and demonstrate the accepted behavour.
Racism
The issue of Racism to Pacific Island students is of great concern.
The majority of the Pacific Islanders have not suffered the abuse
of human rights as a result of racial discrimination experienced
by some races in the Age of Discovery and Colonisation or post-modern
political vicious circle of invasion, conquering, occupation and
ruling in other parts of the world . Most of the pactfic islands
emerged from colonialism with very limited experience of racism
. However, that limited experience does not imply no knowledge of
the suffering that other societies have experienced as consequences
of racial discrimination. But since migration becomes a phenomenon
of the modern era, Pacific island students in entering the school
system have at some stage experienced some form of racial discrimination
or know about some form of racial abuse. They may have by now experienced
some kind of racial stereotyping and social tensions. It is certain
that they entered schools with a bias view of their culture or race
and the school environment may be used to fortify their beliefs.
Beside their awareness of racial discrimination, most pactfic island
students have minimum experience or none at all, in handling any
form of direct racism. Coming from a homogeneous society where these
form of abuse are uncommon, their reaction are unpredictable, and
in most cases a cause for physical violence. Pacific Island cultures
have a very accommodating customs of treating strangers to their
communities whether it is family or village or to behave as stranger
in others. However, since the mode of cultural learning is experiential
the student may have spend more time outside the cultural setting
(country of origin) to learn these skills.
Although there are policies in place to ensure that school are
racially neutral, it would be unrealistic to assume that students
are racial-tint free. Student from different ethnic backgrounds
are informed enough about their ancestral culture to be bias and
sentimental in its favour. The challenge then for the school system
is not only to observe the do's and don'ts of policies but also
to have in place a program encouraging students to learn more about
values which enhanced cultural objectivity, tolerance, awareness
and proper reasoning. This cannot be too hard a task to undertake,
taking into account different views in regard to any subject is
one fundamental principle of democratic societies; same principle
but instead of views from a homogenous society we are considering
view from people of different cultural background.
The social net that scrutinise any issue is broader and culturally
rich. This may call for changes in the curriculum especially in
social science and humanity courses, which in a scientific era,
are gradually being relegated to low priority dumping ground of
inappropriateness in the curriculum.
Violence
One other area of concern with pacific island students is violence.
It does not help when they are being stigmatised as such simply
because they are very physical with what they do. Pacific Island
students, due to the physical demands of their native environment
are very physical in most things they do. From a pactfic island
perspective, verbal duel or abuse and accusation prolong the conflict,
a more physical solution may shorten the conflict and end a prolong
confrontation. If the verbal confrontation is imbalanced by language
ability a pactfic island student can easily resort to physical violence
as countermeasure. At the same time he or she may choose to walk
away.
This does not mean that their cultures lack mediating, negotiation
and conflict resolution skills, it only highlight the fact that
these students do not have the opportunity to learn these skills
in the context of their culture. Pacific islands cultures have one
of the most elaborate system of mediation and negotiation, but the
younger generation especially those who reside overseas lacked any
first hand experience of how these skills are exercised in their
proper cultural context. It would be a worthwhile community or school
project for students to do jointly with elders from their community.
However, these students are further disadvantaged by the failure
of most school to clarify to them the activities that are considered
violent as defined by the Anti-Violence policy. This neglect alone
have victimised a number of pacific island students, where in most
cases they cannot understand why a non-contact act like poking your
tongue or simple act of pushing in the playground are considered
violent. Considering their cultural and physical orientation, these
students should be considered a disadvantage group in this respect,
and a proper orientation program regarding Anti-Violence policy
be implemented in both later primary and early high school years.
Above all that has been discussed so far, Pacific Island students
come from a much more strict and restrictive family environment
in terms of culture and harsh in the sense that forms of corporal
punishment is still the norm in many families. In that respect,
knowledge of their legal right and the limit of parental authority
is something new and like any other they may test its applicability
from time to time; the students may use the school environment as
a testing ground for their social independence. The attitude and
activities that accompanies this transition stage distracted them
from their study.
Taking their cultural and social background in consideration there
are two crucial points to note in dealing with pacific island students:
Firstly the use of 'scare-tactic' in whatever form does not work
with them; Secondly, avoid making any situation confrontational
especially infront of the class or friends. Their pride in their
cultures and self- esteem which, have for a long time been misconceived
as low, is in reality still intact and will disadvantaged them further.
on the other hand, once a trusting relationship is established between
student and teacher, a pactfic island student is obliged not to
do anything to jeopardise that trust, and in most cases compel others
to follow. once that trusting relation is there they are an assets
to teachers in any classroom.
Case Study: Viliami
I am fifteen and my name is Viliami. I was born in Tonga and did
the first three years of primary school there. School was all right
and not far from my home. I learned English at school but only during
English lessons, and the teacher only spoke English during the lessons.
We read books and did spelling tests every day. After the English
class we only spoke Tongan.
In June 1986 my family moved to Australia, and after a week I enrolled
at a primary school. I enjoyed the school very much because the
school had more books and games than the one in Tonga. I also enjoyed
watching children's program on television after school.
The uniforms were nice too and I had to wear shoes every day. The
only thing I found difficult was that I had to speak English all
the time. There were other Tongan kids at school. Some of them spoke
English most of the time and some spoke Tongan as well as English.
I was put into an ESL class to learn English. It was not much different
from what I did in Tonga except that I did not have someone to talk
to in Tongan, so I tried to speak English all the time. one thing
that helped my learning of the language was that I had a very good
friend at school. His parents are from Italy but they have been
in Australia for a long time and he speak English very well. He
helped me a lot to practice my English and we visited each others
home to play and watch television all the time. At the end of the
year, I could speak and write English better.
Now I am at high school. My dad is very strict about doing my homework
and attending school. I never miss school except when I am sick.
Even in my last year in primary school I was not allowed to go with
my friends to the shopping centre except when accompanied by one
of my parents. I am allowed to go on my own now. Every night I have
to finish my schoolwork before I do anything else. Going to school
is the most important thing in my family. With school so important,
truanting from school never crosses my mind. We attend church on
Sunday but sometimes we miss church and attend my rugby league match.
I play for the junior rugby league club in our area.
At my high school it is a different story. I go to a boys high
school now and there are a number of Tongan students there. My first
year at high school was good but most of the Tongan students were
not interested in schooling and they truanted a lot. All the time
they tried to make me join the Tongan gang at school which ruled
the playground. They did not care whether they did well in their
studies or not. They would stay at home, roam around at the shopping
centre or come to school and do nothing except disturb the class.
Most of the Tongan students were not serious with their study but
the school tolerated them because they were good football players.
Their parents are just as strict as mine so I don't know why they
are not punished. I think their parents don't know what is happening
at school.
In my second year I started to hang out with these boys after school
and that was when I really get into trouble with my dad. I got a
belting now and then but I knew that no matter what, my parents
would not allow me to leave school early or not to finish year twelve.
The peer pressure to do what my friends did was growing stronger
as most of them started to leave school as they turned fifteen With
most of my friends not attending school, the time I hung out with
them affected my study very much. I did not concentrate as much
as I should in my school work.
Now I am in Year 1O and I am doing well in Art and all my teachers
are encouraging me to pursue a career in graphic design. My parents
are so strict that I cannot risk truanting and being belted every
time. My father comes round to the school every week and asks all
my teachers for a progress report. Either my father or mother attend
parent's meeting and interviews every time. My mother has helped
our class every year on the school multicultural day festival and
everyone of my friends and teachers liked her. My friends have finally
realised that my parents are so strict that they have started to
be very careful about going around with me because all of us at
any time would get a belting from my dad if he finds me with them
doing something wrong.
Even when I leave school my parents will still be just as strict
with me and will expect me to live at home. They will probably let
me bring my girlfriend home but they will probably be strict with
her too. That is what Tongan parents are like. You are not allowed
to cuddle or kiss, especially in front of the family. Even when
I get married they may expect me to stay at home.
Because I am the eldest son I will gradually be expected to take
over responsibility for the family if my father is not there. one
of my friends already has to take that responsibility all the time
because his father had died. Probably I will still be treated as
a kid when my father is around until I am sixty ! But I hope to
be in charge of my family long before that.
|